The Smart Marty Sky Dispatch

Worldwide AviationSmartMarty.ca
General Aviation

Avoiding LOC-I Part 3: Trim, Landings, and Go-Arounds

If we can get rid of unintentional stalls, we can significantly reduce the number of LOC-I accidents.

Avoiding LOC-I Part 3: Trim, Landings, and Go-Arounds
Featured aviation image for this report.

In parts 1 and 2 of this series, we presented the stats behind 10 years of loss of control in-flight (LOC-I) accidents, and began looking at training to avoid them.

Unless you’re significantly mistimed, it’s hard for a pilot to stall an airplane without pulling back on the stick or causing the autopilot to pull back. So, if you don’t pull back, you’re probably not going to stall. How can you teach yourself or your student not to pull back?

Background

Between 2014 and 2023, we know (from the NTSB reports) that stalls occurred in almost 55% of LOC-I accidents. In most of the rest, we don’t know if one happened or not. Only in a few cases does the NTSB report completely rule out a stall, and most of those accidents are spatial disorientation, flight control malfunctions, or significant weather events.

If we can get rid of unintentional stalls, especially at the “unrecoverable altitudes” we talked about in the first article, we can significantly reduce the number of LOC-I accidents.

Pitch Trim as Stall Prevention Tool

A lot of us tend to think of pitch trim as “cruise control for airplanes.” Once you trim an airplane for a certain speed, changing the power setting doesn’t change the trim speed (at least not much). This is the entire basis for the “pitch for airspeed, power for altitude” school of thought.

But trim also controls how an airplane will behave when you let go of the flight controls. In a trimmed airplane, relaxing your grip on the controls while you look at your tablet or reconfigure the GPS means you won’t be too surprised by what the airplane is doing when you look up. It’s much easier to fly an airplane that wants to do the right thing.

Understanding the Phugoid Oscillation

Changing the power setting may not change your trim speed much, but it does change your airspeed in the short term. When you reduce power, your nose will need to drop a bit to maintain the same angle of attack as the airplane starts descending. Uncontrolled, the nose will overshoot (due to angular momentum) and the airplane will start accelerating. As the airplane accelerates above trim speed, the nose will come back up, overshoot again, and the airplane will decelerate. Then the whole process repeats.

This merry little dance of airspeed, pitch attitude, and altitude is known as a phugoid oscillation. Adding power creates the same dance, as does extending or retracting flaps.

To dampen the phugoid, all you need to do is hold the pitch attitude in its original position for a second or two, and then slowly release control pressure so the attitude slowly moves to its new happy place. By slowing down the pitch change, we reduce the angular momentum, prevent the overshoot, and avoid scaring our passengers.

The Constant Trim Approach

In every airplane, there is a trim setting that will give you your target “over the fence” airspeed with your flaps (if you have them) set for landing. There is also a power setting that will have you flying straight and level at that trim setting with the flaps retracted. That’s a very useful power setting to know.

In the trainers that I typically fly, that trim setting is essentially takeoff trim, and that power setting is somewhere around 2,100 RPM (at least near sea level).

When you’re on downwind (or just outside the FAF, if you’re flying IFR) set the known power setting and trim for hands off flight. For the rest of the flight, leave the trim alone and avoid pulling on the yoke (except to dampen any phugoids, of course).

In a trusty Cessna 172SP Skyhawk, that trim setting will give me about 95 KIAS with the flaps up. 20 degrees of flaps will give me the top end of the approach speed range (~75 KIAS), and 30 degrees will give me the bottom end (~67 KIAS). The speeds are approximate, but if you don’t push or pull unnecessarily on the yoke, you’ll be well within ACS standards.

Use power to keep yourself on glideslope and maybe add 100 rpm or so in turns to keep the sink rate reasonable. Just fly the airplane with your fingertips.

The Landing and Go Around

During our sample period, there were 774 LOC-I accidents on takeoff and 315 LOC-I accidents during a go-around. If we assume about 1 go-around for every 75 or so takeoffs (an educated estimate), a single go-around is about 30 times more likely to result in a LOC-I accident than a single takeoff. I can’t prove it, but I suspect trim plays a larger role than we know.

I‘m not suggesting that go-arounds are dangerous and you should avoid them. But you want to do them the right way.

As you descend into ground effect, it’s time to flare. The bigger and more powerful your airplane, the heavier the control forces, and the more likely you are to start rolling in a bit of nose up trim. That extra trim means you can land the airplane with fine motor skills, and smooth landings impress your passengers.

That same nose up trim can also make the airplane try to kill you on a go around.

A go-around starts with full throttle and a quest for a positive rate of climb. When you add a lot of power suddenly, that nose will want to come up and you have to manage the phugoid. But, if your trim is set more nose up than the takeoff trim setting, just managing the phugoid isn’t enough.

If your trim speed is slow enough, your angle of attack can get very close to a stall. Coupled with minimal control authority (we’re flying slowly) and increased P-factor (left-turning tendency), and we’re getting quite close to a spin. When you see that the trees aren’t getting any smaller, you may even succumb to the temptation to give the yoke a little tug, and now the NTSB is involved.

There are three good defenses here.

Go around early. The further you are from the runway, the less time pressure you’ll feel to get to that positive rate of climb.

Go around a lot. And be consistent about how you do it. Building good muscle memory means that, even if you’re stressed, you’re likely to do the right thing.

Go to the gym. That way you’ll be strong enough to land that fancy airplane without adding nose up trim.

The post Avoiding LOC-I Part 3: Trim, Landings, and Go-Arounds appeared first on AvBrief.com.

Read the original source

Share this aviation story

Back to aviation news