The Smart Marty Sky Dispatch
Performance Mods: Reducing Stall Speed/STOL
Vortex generators and leading-edge cuff kits are tops for lowering stall speed.
We’ll say it up front: In our opinion, STOL mods make an airplane safer and more capable. From the dark end of the flying little airplane spectrum, reducing stall speed potentially may save your life if you have to put the airplane down when and where you would rather not. Reducing touchdown speed means less energy to dissipate if you’re going to come to a stop quickly. Energy is a squared function, so reducing touchdown speed by say, five knots—which most any STOL kit will accomplish—can pay big dividends. Being able to touch down slower means more airports are accessible in that airplane, a nice increase in capability. Some STOL kits provide an increase in gross weight without significantly affecting empty weight, a pleasant return on investment. For twins, one of the STOL kits Vortex Generators (VGs) reduces Vmc, reducing the risk of an out-of-control roll after an engine failure—almost always an event with a fatal ending.
Our rule of thumb for stall speed reduction with STOL kits is on the order of five to eight knots. With a reduced stall speed, final approach speed can be reduced. That’s a good thing, however, because the airplane is in a region of significantly higher drag than at the previous approach speed, training on compensating for that increased drag, a potentially higher sink rate and what must be done to break the descent during the landing flare is required if you don’t want to risk rolling the airplane into an ugly ball. For most production singles, there is plenty of energy to flare and land, power off, after approaching at 1.3 Vso with full flaps. That is not necessarily the case with a reduced stall speed—it may be essential to use power to flare and then get rid of it before touchdown to minimize landing roll. That requires dedicated practice.
In no particular order the following is a select list of top-pick STOL kit manufacturers and a little about each.
Vortex Generators or VGs
Vortex generators were developed in the 1930s. The first manufacturers to take advantage of their capabilities that we can find were Boeing and Learjet. VGs are small pieces of metal attached to the airframe and shaped to create what is often referred to as a horizontal tornado to keep the airflow affixed to the wing and control surfaces at higher angles of attack than would otherwise be possible.
We especially like that the VG kits we’ve seen on single-engine airplanes included VGs on the rudder, increasing its effectiveness for handling crosswinds at the lower landing speeds associated with the lowered stall speeds. We have seen kits that put VGs on the underside of the horizontal stabilizer to allow the elevator to have enough effectiveness to slow the airplane to the new approach and stall speeds.
On twins, VGs reduce VMC and, in many cases, increase the gross weight of the airplane. That makes a big difference on the Cessna 340 and 340A, as an example, which can carry very little weight in the cabin when all the standard and optional fuel tanks are full. The VG kit increases gross weight by 300 pounds when the installed kit weighs less than five pounds.
Micro AeroDynamics holds the STCs for VGs on just about every piston airplane imaginable and as well as agricultural turboprops. Its website is nicely detailed, explaining everything one might want to know about VGs, and gives pricing for each kit. The kits include VGs, installation tools, computer cut templates, drawings, instructions, and adhesive. Over the last 30 years we have had VGs installed on three airplanes in which we had an ownership interest, a Piper Aztec, a Cessna 150, and a Cessna 182. In each case, the process was straightforward and fast, taking slightly less than a day, even when we, who had our one mechanical gene surgically removed at age eight, helped. We observed prices for kits start as low as $750 and go up as the airplane increases in complexity.
BLR Aerospace targets a smaller selection of piston-engine airplanes and some turboprops such as the Cessna 441, with emphasis on the Cessna line and some Piper twins. The website shows all airplanes for which the BLR kit is approved as well as prices. As with Micro AeroDynamics, the BLR kits include everything needed for installation and usually are shipped the day that the order is received. If the buyer wants BLR to paint the VGs, it takes a little longer and there is an additional charge. The lowest price we saw was for the Cessna 180 at $1,495.
Wing Modification Kits
STOL mods started with changing the leading edge of the wing and expanded into including stall fences (a thin fence from the leading to trailing edge of the top of the wing to prevent the stall from propagating outward on the wing—the inboard portion of the wing stalls first on all airplanes), drooped ailerons that move with the flaps, aileron gap seals, lengthening the wing, flap-trim interconnects, joining the flaps and ailerons so that they move together and controlling roll with spoilers or a series of small devices that look like a balanced boat rudder across the top of the wing for most of the span, and installing a canard.
Not surprisingly, the kits could become very expensive, heavy, and take a depressingly long time to install. The kits with spoilers changed roll control dramatically and required some transition time. We’ve flown one on a Bonanza and found it mostly intuitive, while the one we flew on a Cherokee Six was nearly “twitchy” and badly harmonized with the rudder and stabilator.
A tech installing VGs on the rudder of a Cessna 182. This increases its effectiveness for handling crosswinds at lower landing speeds. (Image: Rick Durden)
Over the years the market decided that the most complex designs didn’t provide much improvement over the simpler leading-edge cuff and were not worth the price.
Currently there are several sellers of STOL kits, and it’s worth a prospective buyer’s time to go through the websites carefully to see if their airplane can be modified, what’s involved, if their local shop can do the mod or it has to be done at the mod-shop’s facility, as well as the price and installation time.
Manufactured by Stene Aviation the Sportsman STOL kit dramatically changes the wing leading edge—extending and drooping it, but keeping the original radius—so much so that it adds four square feet to the wing area. It also includes aileron gap seals which, as we have noted, substantially improve roll control response at all speeds. It can be installed on virtually all single-engine Cessnas, is priced at $2,945, and weighs 15 pounds installed. The kit includes inboard composite fairing, new leading-edge skins, transition blocks, new landing light lens assembly, aileron gap seals (except Cessna 206 and 207), all rivets, composite wingtips, installation drawings, instructions, and STC paperwork. It can be installed at Stene in Polson, Montana, or your shop. Stene advertises installation time for a shop that has not done it before at 50 hours. In their shop it takes 27 to 32 hours.
Stene Aviation is also the U.S. dealer for the Canadian-made Wing-X STOL modification. It is targeted at Cessna singles and features an 18-inch extension to each wingtip and spar reinforcement. For most of the aircraft on which it is approved, there is a gross weight increase. Wing-X advertises flight performance increase as much as 30% and gross weight increases up to 400 pounds. The mod can be installed at your shop or at Stene Aviation.
The kit includes the wing extensions (which can be removed in 15 minutes if necessary), and aluminum wing reinforcement straps. Wing-X recommends the work be done by someone with sheet metal and riveting experience. It says that installation takes approximately 42 hours to install. Stene’s website shows a price of $6,095 for the kit.
Now owned and manufactured by Curry Aviation in Leesburg, Florida, the Horton STOL Conversion has been around since the mid-1970s. The mod makes use of a wing leading edge camber and radius change, stall fences to improve roll control at low speeds, conical cambered wingtips that increase wing area slightly and are advertised to increase roll control and reduce wing tip vortex strength, and aileron gap seals that dramatically improve roll control at all speeds. Unfortunately, Curry’s website does not provide a list of aircraft on which the mod is approved nor pricing for the kit.
James Robertson (son of William Robertson, airline owner and sponsor of his employee Charles Lindbergh’s New York to Paris flight) began experimenting with very low-speed flight in the late 1950s. His work evolved into Robertson STOL Conversions for a wide variety of aircraft, both singles and twins, that were renowned for their short-field ability. The conversion involved many moving parts and was heavy, but it worked and owners raved about it. Over the years it steadily lost favor as lighter and simpler mods were developed. Today the mod is only available for some Cessna singles and is marketed by CarlAero.
The conversion consists of a cuffed wing leading edge, an interconnection of the flaps and elevator trim, stall fences, and drooped ailerons. Because of the changes to the wing leading edge, a slight cruise speed increase is advertised for most of the modified airplanes. CarlAero’s website gives no information on weight of the system, pricing, or even contact information for the company.
Although Peterson’s Performance no longer advertises its kits, we think it is worthwhile to mention the company’s STOL products—entire airplanes, including the Kenai and King Katmai. It starts with a Cessna 182, upgrades the power to 300 HP, installs a canard, upgrades the landing gear and avionics to produce two airplanes that get in and out shorter than any other mod for a four-place airplane that we’ve observed, while maintaining cruise speeds over 130 knots. On Peterson’s website we saw that the company had a used 1973 260SE (forerunner of the Kenai/King Katmai series) on sale for $280,000. If a person is in the market for an already STOL modified and beefed-up four-place airplane, we don’t think that there is any available that can match the Kenai or King Katmai.
Final Thoughts
In terms of maximizing odds that a mod will get you what you want in the STOL world, the winner is VGs, hands down. They do what the wing modification kits do for a fraction of the installed price and weight. We’ve flown all of the wing modification STOL mods and need to stick in a couple of observations: 1. They work. 2. Coming in at the normal, book 1.3 Vso approach speed with any STOL mod means that you’re too fast and the airplane will float, sometimes for uncomfortably long distances. 3. It’s a pain in the whatsis to wash an airplane that has VGs installed. 4. VGs are not affected by icing, unless it’s freezing rain (clear ice) as they are too far back on the wing to collect rime ice (and if you’re in freezing rain you’ve got far more severe problems than also icing up the VGs). 5. If you are serious about the shortest landing possible, add VGs to a wing mod kit, but be sure you know how to use power appropriately to flare out of the resulting very slow approach speed. In our reviews, going with a modified wing and VGs, the improvement was measurable, but only just. If you are seriously into STOL ops, then a leading-edge cuff kit and VGs will get you the lowest possible stall speed without getting into reengineering the airplane.
Living in the mountains of Idaho, if we had the money, we’d buy either a Peterson’s Performance Plus Kenai or King Katmai. We were astonished at how slowly they can take off or land, the level nose attitude on landing approach at amazingly low speeds due to the canard (it’s the only STOL airplane we’ve flown where you can clearly see your touchdown area ahead when coming in at a STOL approach speed), and the ability to absolutely stand on the brakes after touchdown because it has a beefed-up nosegear that you aren’t going to break or worry about flipping over as you would in a tailwheel STOL machine. Plus, it cruises as fast or faster than any of the other STOL airplanes in its class.
The post Performance Mods: Reducing Stall Speed/STOL appeared first on AvBrief.com.