The Smart Marty Sky Dispatch

Worldwide AviationSmartMarty.ca
General Aviation

Upgrade Dilemmas: Product Smarts, Long Down Time

It's up to shops and owners to keep big projects on the rails.

Upgrade Dilemmas: Product Smarts, Long Down Time
Featured aviation image for this report.

Having been at both sides of the shop counter as a provider and a customer, I might be numb from the drama of putting an airplane down for upgrades and maintenance, forget the eye-watering costs of it all. Plus more than ever, I can’t find the appeal in flying anything for the first time out of maintenance. The same depressing maintenance-gone-bad wreck reports prove the risks are real.

So when a friend called to tell me about her recent avionics upgrade nightmare (with a harrowing flight test), I tried to be supportive of her venting on the $60,000 stinging experience with an avionics shop that dropped most of the balls. But then it occurred to me that both customers and shops may be getting it wrong more than they get it right. It’s proof in numbers.

When we’ve put out buyer satisfaction surveys like this one over the years (though it doesn’t matter if it’s avionics, maintenance, or paint work) the most common gripes we hear relate to excessive downtime and having to fix stuff after flying away from the shop. There’s also the crapshoot of component reliability and how well shops and manufacturers handle things when the product disappoints. Thing is, many conflicts can usually be avoided when customers and shops have honest discussions, flexibility, and an understanding of what it takes to provide exceptional customer service. The shops that consistently get high marks are the ones that know how to communicate—and that starts before the customer even commits to the project and continues long after the big check clears. It’s a fragile business relationship that can go off the rails, and it makes maintaining your own experimental airplane even more appealing. You answer to yourself.

I got to thinking about it all this past week while working to install Aircraft Extra’s smart oil quantity system for a product field report over in AvBrief’s Experimental Aviator section. For this project, my friend Mark Welch (a thorough builder and maintainer who’s a natural at explaining stuff on and off camera) and I blew the downtime prediction from the beginning when we estimated that Mark’s RV-10 would be buttoned up and flying in a day or so. Yeah, right. When schlepping to the hangar on day three of the project, I wondered how agitated a paying customer would be if it was his machine all over the floor for that long. One of many maintenance rules that should be high on the list: Add a couple of days to the shop’s downtime estimate so you’ll be ecstatic when they hand it back to you early and hopefully squawk free—our project was … check out the video.

The Right Customer Care

For help dealing with avionics buyers who are more demanding than ever, Aircraft Electronics Association (AEA) launched a training initiative for its member shops that’s aimed at shop management and it covers the full spectrum of an area that gets too little attention: customer care. The interactive discussion includes helping the aircraft owner select the right equipment so he won’t fly away with buyer’s remorse, planning the panel interface with the right placement of equipment and accessories, caring for the customer’s aircraft while it’s in the shop’s possession, clearly communicating delays and cost overruns, handling money matters, managing the right support after the sale—it’s a long list of topics worth talking about to keep happy customers coming back for more and bringing their friends. Small shops, in particular, struggle with nailing customer service simply because they don’t have enough staff as everyone focuses on pushing out a safe product that works right the first time. The learning curve can be steep for new techs, and also for old ones trying to wrap the brain around modern interfaces. It’s no wonder the majority of shops polled said they plan to raise labor rates in 2027.

Pulling an engine for an overhaul? Use the downtime to clean up the other stuff—the reality is it’ll be down for longer than you’d want. (Photo: Larry Anglisano)

Flip that 180, where buyers have a responsibility to approach the upgrade process armed with at least some product knowledge because most shops don’t have the time to go deep to explain the full user interface. Buyers should also have a realistic understanding of how much the project will cost, accepting that committing to the upgrade means parting with the airplane for a long time, respecting the shop’s payment terms, and doing everything possible to keep a calm head when hit with bad news.

It’s up to the shop to fill in the knowledge gaps, and it’s why manufacturers invest big in a dealer network to provide quality consulting, a welcoming atmosphere, and a commitment to the customer. There’s no one-sized solution to avionics consulting, but in the end it’s often the good shops that are forced to take on the task of educating. Some aircraft owners when faced with a serious investment aren’t getting much from social media infotainment.

“What I learn from my shop and his team of techs is stuff I’ll never get from watching the masses of showboating influencers who are littering social media these days, but offer little if any educational value,” a newer pilot who owns a Mooney (now with a $90,000 panel) bluntly put it. Maybe some of them can learn from Gary “GPS” Reeves, who does quality Mastery training for Garmin and other products through the Mastering the Modern IFR Cockpit curriculum. He also helps with panel layout decisions, and proudly wears a pink shirt.

Brian Wolfe at NexAir Avionics on Cape Cod in Massachusetts told me that some customers come to the busy shop with research done, while others don’t. For those who haven’t done the work, NexAir’s founder Dave Fetherston prescribes: mission, budget, and technology. “Most of our customers don’t have a good source for avionics training through a flight instructor, leaving us as system experts,” Wolfe told me. Luckily, you won’t have to walk far into NexAir’s hangar to find expertise, in my experience.

It Just Takes Longer

Shops we talk with continue to struggle with staffing, many losing young talent who they’ve trained to the automotive industry where they might make more money with less pressure. Younger shops also struggle with complex interfaces and the reality of tearing into an aging fleet of aircraft where a lot can go wrong. The old saw in the maintenance world goes something about being careful not to open a can of worms and in many ways, total refurbishment is often the better approach to modernization projects like major avionics retrofits rather than working around old wiring and interior components. But start-fresh gut jobs are what hangar queens are made of, and in our surveys we’re always amazed at how long some shops hang on to customer airplanes. “My plane was down for over a year only for me to bring it elsewhere to get the new avionics to work,” we heard from one customer. Avoid the trap and pick the right one by checking references and asking around … bad experiences travel quickly and some stories are ugly.

“The guy who ran my old shop (it went out of business after some scandals) sometimes went long periods without answering the phone or even showing up, and in his abandoned hangar were two airplanes layered with dust from sitting so long,” an owner in Florida told me. But thankfully these troubles aren’t widespread. More common is a task-saturated shop floor with limited techs, and the reasons for delays are almost too long to list.

How long can that take? Garmin’s EIS engine and fuel system interface is hardly a slap-and-go job and one you don’t want to shortchange given the engine work (Photo: Larry Anglisano)

Here’s a common scenario where your bird is at the avionics shop for new flight displays, an autopilot, and a new metal panel. Aside from the reality that this major work requires sizable downtime, lots of wiring, and debugging at the end, other projects can get in the way especially if the shop has to deal with warranty work. I recently gave a talk to a group of avionics shop managers and I asked how they handle warranty matters. You know, finally getting rid of that project that’s been on the floor for far too long only for the owner to call the next day when something doesn’t work as he expects. Unanimously, shop managers said they bring that customer back in right away to fix it. I believe that’s the right approach, even if it causes the delay of other work in progress. The guy who owns the airplane that got pushed off would want the same if it was he who had to come back, no? In the end, it’s a real conversation that every shop should have with customers on the front end of the job.

For the owner, the key is going into any upgrade with a healthy amount of patience and a realistic expectation for downtime and also cost overruns for unexpected issues the shop can’t predict ahead of time. For shops who are sloppy with customer service, it means stepping up to lessen the blow of the unpleasantries that sometimes tag along with wrenching airplanes. It might get worse before it gets better, especially if parts shortages for aging airplanes worsen and the regulatory process for approving new ones gets more expensive and time-consuming. We’ll look deeper into all of this and what it could mean for aircraft maintenance in the coming new year, especially with shops planning to increase labor rates, in an upcoming report in Smart Aviator.

The post Upgrade Dilemmas: Product Smarts, Long Down Time appeared first on AvBrief.com.

Read the original source

Share this aviation story

Back to aviation news